|
State of South Dakota
|
|
EIGHTY-THIRD
SESSION
LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY,
2008
|
|
138P0796
|
SENATE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
NO.
15
|
|
Introduced by:
Senators Kloucek, Greenfield, Hoerth, Koetzle, Maher, McNenny, and
Schmidt (Dennis) and Representatives Putnam, Gassman, Jerke, Nygaard, and
Olson (Betty)
|
A CONCURRENT RESOLUTION,
Urging Congress to oppose efforts to restrict the harvest,
processing, transportation, and export of horses.
WHEREAS,
in recent years, the slaughter and processing of horses has become a
controversial and emotional issue which has resulted in the recent closing of the last horse
processing and slaughter facility in the United States; and
WHEREAS,
animal activists are attempting to prohibit the transportation of horses for
export to slaughter and processing facilities in Mexico and Canada, resulting in the introduction
in Congress of S.311 and H.R.503. This legislation would amend the 1970 Horse Protection Act
to prohibit the possession, sale, or transport of horses for the purpose of slaughter for human
consumption; and
WHEREAS,
the Horse Welfare Coalition estimates that nearly 100,000 unwanted horses
annually will be exposed to potential abandonment and neglect because of the cessation of horse
slaughter in the United States, and efforts to prohibit the transport and export of horses for
slaughter purposes can only exacerbate this problem; and
WHEREAS,
these additional unwanted horses each year will compete for adoption with the
32,000 wild horses that are currently fed and sheltered at public expense at a cost of $40 million;
and
WHEREAS,
the nation's inadequate and overburdened horse rescue and adoption facilities
cannot begin to handle the influx of additional unwanted and abandoned horses each year that
will result from the cessation of equine slaughter, processing, and transport activity; and
WHEREAS,
in the United States the harvest of animals under federal inspection is highly
regulated to provide for humane handling of the animals as well as for a safe and wholesome
product. Horse processing in the United States has been the most tightly regulated of any animal
harvest, and the horse is the only animal whose transportation to processing was regulated; and
WHEREAS,
horse processing plants in the United States are required to have United Stated
Department of Agriculture (USDA) veterinarians supervise the euthanasia of each horse.
Euthanasia occurs before processing, and the euthanasia method is humane, according to the
American Veterinary Medical Association and the United States Department of Agriculture; and
WHEREAS,
the USDA estimates that 35,000 horses were sent to Canada for slaughter in
2007, an approximate forty-one percent increase from the previous year, while horse slaughter
exports to Mexico have more than tripled, a likely result of the closure of slaughter and
processing plants in the United States. Equine slaughter in many foreign facilities is not held to
the standards for humane handling and euthanasia required in the U.S. and often involves
practices that would not be tolerated in this country; and
WHEREAS,
in many cultures around the world horsemeat is commonly used for human
consumption, and there is a significant export market for this product. Cessation of equine
slaughter in the United States will not prevent human consumption horses; and
WHEREAS,
another important use of horsemeat is in diets for many zoo animals. Equine
protein mimics what the animal would receive in the wild. The closure of horse processing
facilities in the U.S. will eliminate the only USDA-inspected source for this meat; and
WHEREAS,
there is a critical need for humane horse processing facilities in the United
States to reduce the suffering inflicted on unwanted and abandoned horses and to meet overseas
export markets for horsemeat in a humane manner; and
WHEREAS,
the people of South Dakota have a strong agricultural economy and culture and
do not believe in inflicting our cultural values onto other societies:
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED,
by the Senate of the Eighty-Third Legislature
of the State of South Dakota, the House of Representatives concurring therein, that the
Legislature urges the United States Congress to support the resumption of horse processing in
the United States and to offer incentives that help create horse processing plants throughout the
United States; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED,
that the Legislature strongly urges Congress to oppose S.
311 and H.R. 503 and any efforts to restrict equine slaughter or the transportation of horses for
such purposes.